GNCHR expresses concerns over the planned return hub in Rwanda
The Greek National Commission for Human Rights (GNCHR), the National Human Rights Institution in Greece and the independent advisory body to the Greek State on matters pertaining to human rights protection, is closely monitoring the joint initiative by Greece, Austria, Germany, Denmark and the Netherlands to establish a “return hub” in Rwanda, announced in Vienna on 16 November.
According to the announcements made, the five States intend to enter into negotiations with Rwanda aiming to transfer there third-country nationals who no longer have a right to remain in the European Union and cannot be returned to their countries of origin.
The GNCHR recognises that the effectiveness of return procedures is a legitimate component of a coherent migration policy. However, the externalisation of return procedures to third countries with which the persons concerned may have no prior connection represents a significant paradigm shift in European return policy and raises serious concerns regarding the protection of fundamental rights and accountability.
The new Regulation (EU) 2026/2280 (EU Return Regulation) now permits returns to third countries, subject to specific conditions and safeguards. This provision of the Regulation does not, however, relieve the States concerned of their obligation to ensure, at every stage, compliance with minimum human rights protection standards and the individual assessment of the specific needs and circumstances of the persons concerned. Nor does it remove the obligation to ensure that each individual agreement and each transfer decision fully complies with the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union and the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR).
These concerns are particularly relevant in the case of Rwanda. The United Kingdom’s previous attempt to implement a different, albeit related, mechanism for transferring asylum seekers to Rwanda demonstrated the serious risks that such models may entail.
At the same time, rapporteurs of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) have already called on the States concerned not to proceed with the proposed scheme, highlighting serious legal and humanitarian concerns. Similarly, the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights has underscored the risks associated with the proposal put forward by the five States.
Beyond the specific legal safeguards at stake, the GNCHR is concerned about the proportionality and the human dimension of a mechanism that provides for the transfer of people to a third country with which they have no prior connection. Migration management cannot treat individuals as objects to be moved from one country to another. Respect for human dignity requires that every return measure take into account the individual concerned, their personal circumstances and the consequences that the transfer may have on them.
Questions also arise regarding the proportionality of the financial cost of the initiative. The GNCHR considers that the actual cost per person transferred, including the costs of transfer, accommodation, operation, monitoring and any subsequent return, should be made public and assessed against alternative return and reintegration policies in countries of origin. The effective management of public and European resources is an essential element in assessing the necessity and proportionality of such a complex and potentially costly mechanism.
The GNCHR further stresses the need for full clarification of the legal nature and content of the agreement with Rwanda, the sharing of responsibility among the States concerned, the procedures for individual assessment and judicial protection, and the mechanisms for independent monitoring and accountability. The conclusion of the relevant agreement by individual Member States rather than by the European Union itself must not result in loopholes in EU-level and judicial scrutiny or in the protection afforded by the Charter of Fundamental Rights.
The GNCHR calls on the Greek State, before any agreement with Rwanda is finalised, to make public the content and legal form of the envisaged framework and to ensure prior and substantive scrutiny of its compatibility with Greece’s international and EU obligations.
The effectiveness of return policy cannot be pursued to the detriment of the effective protection of fundamental rights, nor can it entail shifting responsibility for their protection beyond Europe’s borders. In any event, the purported effectiveness of such measures is seriously called into question and is not supported by empirical evidence.
